Transparency in call pay: Can it cure medical staff division?

Transparency in call pay: Can it cure medical staff division?


When call pay is creating division in a medical staff, it’s often because of the way contracts are negotiated. The most common approach is to negotiate with one specialty at a time behind closed doors. The lack of transparency in this approach has negative effects on hospital culture. For one, it fuels rumors that do not accurately reflect arrangements. It also pits specialties against one another in a fight for the same call pay dollars, and many believe that only those with political sway will be heard and adequately compensated. In other words, it is not believed to be a fair process. As a result, the hospital suffers from an environment of distrust and division, not only between medical staff and administration, but also between specialty groups.


That’s why we designed our Physicians’ Call Committee to be a platform for transparency. Our process was developed in 2005 with the help of physician leaders at Winchester Medical Center in Virginia, who were facing a call pay crisis. They believed that physician leaders should drive decisions on inclusion because they understood burden better than anyone. Former medical staff president at Winchester, Dr. Tom Oliver, said, “[We] felt strongly that while funding of the program would be the hospital’s responsibility, decisions on specialties to be included/excluded…should be decided by [the call committee] based upon available funding each year. It was felt such an arrangement would improve objectivity of the process.”


The committee, which is made up of 5 to 7 voting members, including an emergency room physician and a member of administration, works to develop a relative value for the burden of call for each specialty, not just those demanding to be paid. This is achieved using a fairness standard that goes beyond fair market value. After the burden of call is established for each specialty, the specialties are placed in tier groups and the call pay budget is allocated appropriately. The committee’s recommendations are shared with the medical staff before they are presented to the administration to ensure that call pay is no longer shrouded in secrecy.


This process transforms call pay from a point of contention to a source of good will. The simple fact that a process has been put in place to ensure the fairness of call pay arrangements goes a long way in the alignment of medical staffs with administrations. It also eases tensions between specialty groups. Even if there are specialties not being paid, they understand why, and they understand that the decision came out of a fair and transparent process.


Our clients have found that the Physicians’ Call Committee has led to a higher level of satisfaction surrounding call pay. Dr. Tom Oliver said: “Complaints about call have largely disappeared from the medical staff executive agenda. That’s the biggest thing that’s happened, is we just don’t hear people complain about it as much, so I think what it’s meant to the staff is a lower level of grief in general. Nobody likes taking call, but when you know you’re being recognized for it in some way then you’re just a little bit less unhappy about taking it. It hasn’t made us all happy physicians every time we’re taking call. We’re just less unhappy if I can put that in a positive way. I think that’s the biggest thing.”



Complete the form below and receive a copy of our latest white paper: Increasing Hospital Profitability
Something went wrong. Please check your entries and try again.

Want to Learn More?

Check out these additional resources for the Call Pay Solution®, our three-phase, six-step process that empowers your organization to create a more fair, transparent and sustainable call pay plan.

Community Culture: A Top Physician Concern

By Kyle Worthy | August 13, 2019

Community Culture: A Top Chysician concern By: Leah Worthy A recent Jackson Physician Search survey polled rural physicians and administrators on the factors that influence recruitment. While both parties agreed that compensation is a top influencer, it was their differing opinions that revealed the more interesting insights. For example, administrators underestimated the importance of culture-related…

Building The Ideal Call Committee

By Kyle Worthy | July 24, 2019

Building The Ideal Call Committee By: Kyle Worthy A Physicians’ Call Committee can be a hospital’s inside track to success. The benefits of a committee extend beyond compensation. A committee can encourage physician alignment, enhance culture, and provide a platform for deeper engagement. But when a committee has not been structured properly, it tends to…

Case Study: Hospital CEO finds solution to call budget unpredictability

By Kyle Worthy | July 2, 2019

Case Study: Hospital CEO finds solution to call budget unpredictability By: Kyle Worthy Summary: Predictability in budgeting is everything. But for many hospital administrators, the rising cost of call pay and the constant possibility that yet more specialty groups will come forward asking for call pay makes setting a budget extremely difficult. But Bill Caldwell,…

Compensation programs in the age of uncertainty

By Kyle Worthy | June 19, 2019

Compensation programs in the age of uncertainty By: Kyle Worthy As we met with physicians over the past few weeks, we noticed that many of them had a common concern: what will happen to their call pay plan if… There is a multitude of uncertainties in healthcare today as more and more hospitals consolidate to…


Compensation Strategies to Attract, Retain and Reward Your Physician Talent.


Charlotte, NC



Office Hours:
M-F 8:00am – 5:00pm EST

Charlotte, NC
P:  877-643-7520
F:  800-314-8281
M-F: 8AM - 5PM