Securing Call Coverage: Is employment the answer? 

Cover Image Concpet

When determining the fair market value of on-call compensation rates, the latest Sullivan Cotter survey is the most frequently used resource. At MaxWorth, we don’t believe survey results should be the sole factor in the decision-making process. Surveys are often flawed, and their rates are unsustainable for most organizations, which prohibits broader inclusion in call pay programs. Still, these surveys typically shed light on developing trends in the industry and this year’s update was no exception.


Sullivan Cotter’s 2018 survey revealed that 53% of healthcare organizations struggle to secure physicians to provide call coverage. Many hospitals have tried to fix this problem by employing physicians, which has led to an unprecedented surge in physician employment. Now that more doctors are employed than ever before, why are hospitals still struggling to meet EMTALA requirements?


Independent Physician Concerns


Many facilities struggle to contract with independent groups for on-call coverage where there are service line shortages that will increase physicians’ frequency of taking call. Independent physicians are also reluctant to serve on a call panel where there is a low probability of reimbursement. These issues, which result in petitions for increased payment, contribute to the impulse to employ physicians.


Increased Competition


While employment may seem like a natural solution, it is often financially prohibitive. As competition for physician talent rises, compensation is increasing, and hospitals simply cannot afford to employ all specialties needed on a call panel. Most hospitals are losing money on their employment arrangements as it is. This is especially true for rural facilities. As a result, many facilities now have mixed medical staffs of employed and private practicing physicians.


Mixed Staff Complexities


Mixed medical staffs often become divided around compensation issues like call pay. While call pay is included in employed physicians’ contracts, private practicing physicians are typically paid a per diem. There is often a lack of understanding between these groups concerning how and why each side gets paid, resulting in a perceived lack of fairness and demands for more pay. These demands place administrators, who are already seeking ways to contain costs, in a difficult position.


A Path Forward


It’s becoming clear that employment is at best a part of a larger solution. A holistic approach to compensation is needed that aligns medical staffs around call coverage. MaxWorth’s Call Pay Solution is designed to align the medical staff with a fair, transparent, and inclusive program that also supports the financial sustainability of the hospital.  

Hospitals that have implemented this solution have been able to attract and retain key physicians, allowing them to maintain a strong emergency department and continue to deliver quality care to their communities in today’s challenging environment.



Complete the form below and receive a copy of our latest white paper, Call Pay Solution: Stabilizing call budgets with a fair and sustainable approach

Something went wrong. Please check your entries and try again.

Want to Learn More?

Check out these additional resources for the Call Pay Solution®, our three-phase, six-step process that empowers your organization to create a more fair, transparent and sustainable call pay plan.

The impact of call coverage on a hospital’s reputation

The impact of call coverage on a hospital’s reputation Hospitals tell us that nearly 80 percent of their patients come through their emergency departments. That means that the majority of patients are directly affected by which service lines are available on call. Therefore, this availability (or lack thereof) has an…

Proposed legislation could impact physician compensation

Proposed legislation could impact physician compensation Most patients assume their care will be covered by insurance as long as they go to an in-network hospital. But this is not the case if they’re treated by an out-of-network physician. Patients in this situation can end up with surprise medical bills for…

Curbing ED costs could save rural hospitals

Curbing ED costs could save rural hospitals A recent study confirms that rural hospitals are threatened by significant financial instability. Out of the country’s 1,844 rural hospitals, 453 are vulnerable to closure. In fact, nearly 50% are operating in the red, and this number is steadily increasing, evidenced by the…

Ambulance diversion and the struggle to secure 365 coverage

Ambulance diversion and the struggle to secure 365 coverage Last week, a bill was introduced in congress that would require hospitals to report instances of diversion. Failure to do so would result in funding cuts. Diversion is the practice of turning away ambulances when an emergency department is full. The…